Tuesday, November 16, 2010

Culture and the Wiki (Post #1)

Article - College 2.0: Wiki Project Brings Some Student Wariness at Singapore Management U

In the push to expand technological capabilities, some school personnel are learning an important lesson .... Culture Matters and can impact technological receptiveness. In an interesting article, College 2.0 writer, Jeff Young reports that a number of 1st year students at Singapore's Management University were wary of using the Web 2.0 technology, the Wiki, after learning that they would be able to edit the writings of their fellow classmates. Many students felt that the idea of the wiki could lead to the cultural notion of "losing face." Two Asian students made the following statements:
  • "Its dangerous, actually, I can change everything that others have done."
  • "It's a very Asia context. You have to be more aware of others and have sensitivity to others."  
Jason Woodard, Assistant Professor of Information Systems followed up the students commentary by noting: "People were very reluctant to edit things that other people posted, I guess out of deference. People were very careful to not want to edit their peers. Getting  people out of that mind-set has been a real challenge."

____________________

Any Thoughts?

Saturday, November 13, 2010

Wikipedia Cartoon

This week my blog posting was about Wikipedia and its future potential to become an accepted scholarly resource. The overall consensus from my fellow IDE 611 classmates is that Wikipedia is a good informational resource when one is aiming for quick and easy convenience in finding answers in an informal fashion; however, in terms of using it for academic or important research assignments, there was hesitancy due to the editability feature and need for information verification associated with Wikipedia.

I came across the Cartoon below which succinctly highlights one of  the main key critique of Wikipedia.



Visual Image Source: http://virtualeconomics.typepad.com/.a/6a00d8341c5b7853ef00e553fdeb818834-800wi

Friday, November 12, 2010

What is Wikipedia?

Below is a Youtube.com video that gives a brief introduction to Wikipedia (An evolving information resource). The video addresses the issues of bias, reliablity, expert knowledge and accurracy in relation to Wikipedia.



Wikipedia: Benath the Surface
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QY8otRh1QPc

Monday, November 8, 2010

College 2.0: Can Wikipedia attain the status of a scholarly resource?



A few weeks ago in the online discussion for IDE 611, the question was raised if Wikipedia was considered a reliable and scholarly resource.  The above article brings the issue of source reliability and Wikipedia to light once again. Specifically, the non-profit Wikimedia Foundation, the creators of Wikipedia and other Internet wiki projects are committed to significantly improving the content accuracy of Wikipedia because as they readily admit with the current state of affairs and educational expectations, "Citing Wikipedia in your footnotes is an easy way to get an F on your term paper" due to "inaccurate, incomplete and often downright suspicious articles."

To address the above scholarly concerns, the Wikimedia Foundation have launched an improvement campaign entitled, "Public Policy Initiative" (PPI) in which they are calling for educators and college students to act as "critical editors" for the Wikipedia website.  Nine public policy professor from educational institutions such as Harvard University, George Washington University, Indiana University-Bloomington, and Syracuse University have agreed to participate in the PPI pilot program. The professors will employ a variety of instructional approaches and methods for integrating Wikipedia into their academic courses.

  • Do you think in the future Wikipedia will eventually be accepted as a scholarly resource? If yes or no, please elaborate on your response.

Tuesday, November 2, 2010

College 2.0: Should the use of technology be banned in the college classroom?


There seems to be a heated debate taking place in university and college settings about the use of technology in the classroom. On one side of the debate are faculty members who believe that the use of technology in the college classroom is taking away from the overall level of high quality teaching, while on the opposite end of the spectrum there are faculty that believe the increase use of technology in the college classroom is a continuing trend that can improve and promote better quality teaching. 


Professor Mark James
In the attached article, readers are introduced to both sides of the debate. For example, Professor Mark James (University of West Florida) prohibits students from using their laptops in class and advises them to silence their cellphones.  Professor James states,  "The students seem more involved in the discussion than when I allowed them to go online.  They were more attentive, and we were able to go into little more depth."

In contrast, there is Professor Joanne Budzien who is receptive to technology in the college classroom, but  recommends that all instructors must contextualize the need and use of the technology to the needs and learning outcomes of their students. Specifically, Professor Budzein discusses her decision to not use clickers in her small classes. She stated, "My classes are very small - I have 24 students, and it just seems impersonal to put up a question and use a clicker.  I just have a raise of hands, and I can call on them and say why do you think this and why do you think that."

Personally, I do not believe that technology in the college classroom is a bad  thing; however, I firmly believe that technology is a tool and not a substitute for good and effective teaching. The selected technology should always support the instructor's content material and learning outcomes.

Which side of the debate do you fall on? If neither side appeals to you, please explain.

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

New Topic: Auto-Tunes and Autotune the News

For the 2nd half of the semester, I will be concentrating on Auto-Tunes in the classroom and Auto-Tune the News. These are two separate topics that align with one another

Auto-Tune
Antares Autotune 4
Auto-Tune is a proprietary[2] audio processor created by Antares Audio Technologies. Auto-Tune uses a phase vocoder to correct pitch in vocal and instrumental performances. It is used to disguise off-key inaccuracies and mistakes, and has allowed singers to perform perfectly tuned vocal tracks without the need of singing in tune. While its main purpose is to slightly bend sung pitches to the nearest true semitone (to the exact pitch of the nearest tone in traditional equal temperament), Auto-Tune can be used as an effect to distort the human voice when pitch is raised/lowered significantly.[3]
Reference:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auto-Tune
               ________________________________________________________
Auto-Tune the News
The Gregory Brothers
The Gregory Brothers first became well known for a series of YouTube videos, Auto-Tune the News, in which recorded voices of politicians, news anchors, and political pundits were digitally manipulated to conform to a melody, making the figures appear to sing.

Although they had been featured on national television as early as 2009 for these political satires, the Gregory Brothers experienced a surge of recognition in the summer of 2010 with the release of episode 12b of the series, titled "Bed Intruder Song", which had little connection to American politics. Following the mainstream success of that music video, the Gregory Brothers have focused less on political satire in their works, but they still source most of the footage they use from American news organizations.
Reference:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Gregory_Brothers
                  ________________________________________________________
An example of Auto-Tune in the classroom is Winston Churchill speech, "Lift Up Your Heart"

Students could do any of the following:
  • Rhetorical anaylsis of the speech
  • Historical/contextual anaylsis of the speech
  • Comparison/contrast with another speech during the same time period
  • Biographical study of Churchll and the significance of the speech

Monday, October 18, 2010

Irish Charities and Digital Storytelling

After being hit hard by the global economic downturn, Ireland is embarking on an ambigious social campaign via digital storytelling. Specifically, an online news article reported that "hundreds of charities around the country are expected connect with volunteers and suppoerters through digital storytelling." Not only is this endeavor going to be a new and unique way to recruit potential donations and volunteers for a multitude of organizations, but it is also a low cost way in which said organizations can highlight the work that they do through the medium of online digital storytelling.

http://www.bettertogether.ie/
What makes the endeavor so interesting is that it is a national campaign and at the Web site, www.bettertogether.ie which will be showcasting the various digital stories in the "About Us" tab, the following sentiment is expressed: "Studies show that societies with high levels of social involvement experience less crime, less violence and enjoy better mental health...By getting involved in voluntary and community activity YOU can help make Ireland a better place." I found this comment so inspiring and I wish more Americans could follow the path of the Irish and involve themselves more in charitable and volunteer work.

Finally, the new article announced that the top 3 digital storytelling videos will receive 3,000 euro for charity.

Please see link to news article below:
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ukpress/article/ALeqM5hny72IW13ODseOpckFdv_g05kfBA?docId=N0258091286986569410A

An example of one of the charities using digital storytelling
Educate Together


Organisation name: Educate Together

The Organisation's Website: http://www.educatetogether.ie

About the organisation:
Educate Together is a charity and educational patron body. There are 58 Educate Together multi-denominational schools in Ireland. It pioneers an approach to education in Ireland that is inclusive of all learners irrespective of belief system, race, ethnicity, class, culture, gender, language, lifestyle and ability.
Public Contact Details:
www.educatetogether.ie
01 4292500
Find us on Facebook!